Explain your rating system!

I need a better system for giving stars because I feel like I’m always giving 1, 3 or 5 stars.

Here’s my general criteria: 1 star: no effort, didn’t follow the theme, joined late and not wearing anything, didn’t change from last round (or the white fur suit, plain white, hot dog costume, spamming pose 28 (don’t hate me for that one, I’ve only ever seen trolls do it) lastly, if you’re being rude to other people in the server, you’ll probably get a 1 star from me

2 stars: bare minimum, an outfit that is a carbon copy of something we have seen a million times before, overdone

3: creative, some effort put in, but could have used more. Some layering. (Idc if it’s clipping, it’s not the players fault), a few overused items

4: this was planned out and well thought out. Mix of different items/materials if it fits the theme. Different shades/colors., one or two overused items

5: insanely creative, wish I thought of this, I’m jealous lol, no overused items, good use of color, makeup and hair, custom makeup is not a necessity, neither is VIP. It’s about how you use what is provided.

I don’t care much about poses unless it really adds to the look! Tell me your criteria! This is for REGULAR servers! Pro servers scare me!!