If Total Drama ever did a second All Stars season, here is who I think they’d cast(Spoiler tag is for if I mention the second reboot season)

So when it comes to selecting people for a second All Stars season, there are a LOT of characters you can pick and since there are four casts, not every cast is gonna get an equal chance to shine. So today, I decided I’m gonna talk about who I think have the best chances of returning to a second All Stars season if the show ever does one again(since they clearly have no qualms about de-canonizing the fifteen year timeskip).

For this cast roster, I am going to be picking eight cast members from the Island and Reboot casts and five members from the ROTI and Pahkitew casts.

Island cast: Owen, Gwen, Heather, Duncan, Leshawna, Courtney, Cody, and Noah

Reboot cast: Priya, Bowie, Millie, Julia, Wayne, Raj, MK, Damien

ROTI cast: Lightning, Zoey, Scott, Jo, Brick

Pahkitew cast: Shawn, Sky, Sugar, Jasmine, Dave

Teams:

Heroes: Owen, Gwen, Leshawna, Cody, Zoey, Brick, Shawn, Jasmine, Priya, Millie, Wayne, Raj, Damien

Villains: Heather, Duncan, Courtney, Noah, Lightning, Scott, Jo, Sky, Sugar, Dave, Bowie, Julia, MK

Honorable Mentions that didn’t make the cut: Izzy, Harold, Beth, Alejandro, Cameron, Mike, Max, Scarlett, Ella, Emma, Chase, Zee, Ripper, Caleb

Now I don’t feel like going into a full-on analysis as to why I made the picks I did so any discussions about this cast I made can be made in the comments